Julien Menielle@jmnlInstagram

Est-ce que TikTok nous rend VRAIMENT accro ? On fait le test ! La vidéo complète sur DTC (lien sur le

… more

what it claims

TikTok and its short-form videos act as a modern hypnosis tool, causing real addiction and a loss of control over our time and attention.

mixed

The idea that short-form TikTok videos capture our attention intensely is based on solid scientific foundations.

noli's read

The idea that short-form TikTok videos capture our attention intensely is based on solid scientific foundations. A 2024 systematic review analyzing 26 empirical studies (published in PMC) confirms that problematic use of the platform is correlated with attention difficulties, stress, and procrastination. Furthermore, observational research from Baylor University explains this compulsive behavior through a phenomenon of 'time distortion' induced by the algorithm. Conversely, the illustration of hypnosis or total control (like Kaa the snake) is a highly exaggerated visual metaphor: it is a loop of habits and rapid gratification, not an absolute loss of free will. Finally, while there are real challenges regarding focus, labeling this as systematic addiction for everyone lacks evidence, as effects vary greatly depending on user sensitivity. A study from RCSI University of Medicine published in 2026 also points out that it is excessive consumption, not moderate use, that impairs our daily attention capabilities.

the sources

Claimed by Julien Menielle. Noli grades the claim, never the person.

Decoded by Noli · July 13, 2026 · the original post

What the graded evidence says

Evidence: C

Linked to, not proven to cause.

Effect: loneliness/depression after limiting social media (RCT); association of problematic smartphone use with poor sleep, anxiety, depression — reduced loneliness and depressive symptoms when limiting social media to ~30 min/day for 3 weeks (small RCT); problematic use robustly associated with poorer sleep and mood
Measured on: young adults / students (RCT); broad samples for the association

The randomized evidence is limited and small-scale; the strong links to poor sleep and mood are largely associational. Benefits are modest and individual.

Julien Menielle in the Register102 claims graded · solidity 91/100See their record →